I give talks and interviews on Palestine daily. I also travel the world giving talks; in one recent trip to Australia and New Zealand I gave 212 talks in 17 cities (average four per day). The most embarrassing question I get asked frequently is along the lines of “with the most just cause in the world and the most ruthless colonizers, why do you Palestinians have such incompetent corrupt leaders?” My late friend Edward Said wrote about the Palestinian authority extensively and prophetically write a scathing article about the Oslo Accords in October 1993 (https://www.lrb.co.uk/the-paper/v15/n20/edward-said/the-morning-after). His books and writings were thus banned in the Palestinian areas for a while by the late Yassir Arafat. I was not as strong a critic as he was. But after returning to Palestine in 2008 I learned so much more about the inner workings of the hooligans who signed this “surrender document” and were placed by Israel and the US to run the civil affairs of our people under occupation so I became more critical and less forgiving.
My life’s work over the past 40 years of activism was focused against the Zionist onslaught on our people and our environment. I wrote hundreds of research and other articles, over 30 chapters in books, and several books. I discussed in these and some interviewed shortcomings including corruption, collusion with occupiers via security coordination, incompetence and removal or marginalization of Fatah people of good will and importance (people like Afif Safieh, Ihab Bseiso, Marwan Barghouthi, Nabil Saath). I started to compile data. I befriended critics like Nizar Banat (who was killed by the Authority) and Basil Al-Araj (jailed and mistreated by the authority and killed by Israel). The data and material I accumulated corruption is voluminous and I may end up putting it in a book later. 98% of my time remained focused on fighting colonial racist Zionists. But I also was harassed by governments (including Israel, Jordan, USA, and indeed the Palestinian authority). The older I get, the more experience tells me I need to speak out more.
When I researched my book on popular resistance in Palestine, I understood how much damage the authority caused and still causes to all forms of resistance including popular resistance (unarmed). But I also learned increasingly that their biggest sin is “ego”, not being willing to admit their mistakes (be it in Jordan, Lebanon, or the biggest mistake of all: Oslo agreements). Oslo as Edward Said labeled it was our second Nakba. If the Zionists do succeed in liquidating the Palestinian cause, you can squarely put the blame largely on the signing of Oslo and its ramifications. The second mistake was not leaving Oslo after the interim 5 years “transition period” of Oslo ended in 1999. But an equally important mistake (sin) was not using the opportunity of governance to develop a system of governance based on law which respects all segments of our society rather than promote those who kiss ass to the leader regardless of their corruption or incompetence.
Thus, year after year the corruption and incompetence grew worse especially in the areas most critical for our Palestinian cause. For example, the foreign service appointments: “ambassadors” who are appointed for political purposes and who know very little and harm the cause rather than help it. This is a generalization that applies to 99% of our representatives. Exceptions like the brilliant (and friend) Husam Zumlot our representative in the United Kingdom actually prove the failure and incompetence of others. But other areas clearly saw corruption and nepotism become systematic and malignant. Even in areas like the environmental protection where good people were removed and subservient individuals promoted regardless of competence. Government contracts are handed out not on meritocracy on cleptocracy.
I, like Edward Said and millions of Palestinians, disagreed
strongly with the choices made by this Oslo group to build the Palestinian administration
that relieved Israel from cost of occupation and from International isolation
based on not even promises of freedom or return of rights. But I
also can't help but feel sorry for those who took that path. It must be very
painful for a human being to go down a tunnel where there is no possibility of
a light at the end and during this trip into the depths of darkness feel the
leaches crawling up his back sucking his blood and voices from behind calling
him back (some of them his political enemies, others ex-comrades in Fatah).
Palestinian negotiators are fearful of going back because they think it might
give political opponents a PR tool. They are just fearful of losing face; I am
always grateful to a wise advisor who 30 years ago convinced me to drop this
fear of admitting mistakes. They may also be fearful of losing a job, or fear
that the alternative to Fatah maybe just as bad, fear of Israel, or fear of the
US or just simply fear of their own power. But ultimately fear is a lack
of self-confidence to take another course. And their fear should be balanced by
the fact that people are literally dying for justice and wanting leaders to
care about them and not about themselves
The leaders had many chances to admit mistakes and reset the course: 1)
the assassination of Yitzhak Rabin and elections of the right wing Netanyahu
government in the 1990s; 2) the murder of Yasser Arafat in 20004; 3) the Palestinian
elections in 2006, 4) the opportunity created by the Gaza Ghetto uprising and
the ongoing genocide. The latter is
particularly important since it may be the last chance to reset the course. How
do you reset the course: get rid of corruption, reform the judiciary to be
truly independent, end the unilateral decisions, bring the masses of
Palestinians with intellectual abilities to replace all the corrupt people,
leverage our only golden asset: our people. Yes, this is not going to be easy,
but you can start. Palestinians do not have to line-up with governments. We do
have to 1) speak truth to power, 2) build something positive despite incredible
odds, 3) try to find and encourage the goodness in ALL humans. Briefly, we must
challenge corruption and greed that leads to war and conflict. We see both large
scale greed and corruptions: Trump, Biden/Harris, the rulers of Saudi Arabia
and the UAE and General Sisi of Egypt, and our own corrupt Palestinian “leaders”.
How do we make sure that people we know do not continue down that path
(addictive/destructive)? Fatah and other factions can redeem themselves if we
get strong intellectual leadership. But this must emerge from the bottom and go
up. People can make a difference. With courage and conviction, Palestine can
rise like the Phoenix from the ashes. You/we owe it to over a quarter million
martyrs, a million injured, we ow it to the millions of refugees. We owe it to
our children, grandchildren and generations to come. We owe it to the
dismembered bodies of Palestinian children. We owe it to the fidayyeens who
paid the ultimate price of resistance. We owe it to the hundreds of millions
around the world who declared in the streets of every city in the world “in our
thousands, in our millions, we are all Palestinians.” We owe it to Palestine
and to the world. Let us work hard NOW to start a dialogue and start organizing…
